We signed up to 12 AI girlfriend apps. Here's the first ten minutes on each
Pick what would put you off, or pick an app, and read what happened in our first ten minutes. Every log is from our own free account.
Twelve sign-ups, logged
Free accounts on 12 apps, nothing paid and no trials. Eight on 14 and 15 November 2026, four on 17 October 2026. Messages typed the way people text.
What would put you off?
Read an app's log
12 apps, free accounts, nothing paid
SpicyChat
Before you type
Nothing. Pick a bot and start.
Her opener
Evelyn Hayes, a survival romance with 731,000 chats, opens with a gun at your back in a looted pawn shop. Four meters run across the top: Trust, Love, Attraction and Infection.
Our reply
Offering her half of whatever we found moved nothing. Pointing out a can of peaches 'as a down payment' earned '+3 Trust'. Replies came back in seconds.
The paywall
None in our session. The paid plans sell memory, from €5.95 a month.
The smoothest ten minutes of the twelve, if you like your romance with a plot.
Read the SpicyChat reviewHeyGF
Before you type
One question: should she write like a real person, in short texts, or roleplay longer scenes? We picked Real chat.
Her opener
'Tell me something interesting about yourself.' Flat, for a girl with a whole written backstory.
Our reply
We admitted to coming third in a pub quiz out of four teams. Three texts came straight back: 'Third out of four? Babe that's adorable', then her own undefeated Wednesday quiz in Manchester, then a question for us.
The paywall
We asked for a selfie. It arrived locked behind an 'Open now' button, with our balance at 0 coins.
The most natural texting we found. Pictures are where the money starts.
Read the HeyGF reviewKindroid
Before you type
A starter companion, Mika, was already waiting, with a banner saying the premium model was ours for a limited time.
Her opener
A snowbound inn called the Lantern's Rest: 'Come in. Warm your hands, breathe, and let the wind forget your name.'
Our reply
We asked whether she ran the place alone. The wind had kept the hearth with her 'for many winters', and a tray of tea slid our way. A few seconds' wait.
The catch
That polish is borrowed. Prices only appear once you press Subscribe, and the three tiers stack on top of each other.
The calmest start of the lot. Just remember the model charming you is the paid one, on loan.
Read the Kindroid reviewDream Companion
Before you type
Nothing to fill in, but a 20-minute 'new user' discount countdown and a No-Nut November sale banner.
Her opener
Live Action: Maya, 23, on video on a sofa, with a ladder of ten levels beside her, each unlocking something more explicit.
Our reply
She texts like a person, lowercase and short, and asked what work we'd come home from. Each message earned 5 XP of the 30 a level needs.
The paywall
Skipping a level costs 15 coins. Plans are quoted by the day: $0.40 a day for Premium on monthly billing.
A girlfriend app that plays like a game, with the meter in plain view.
Read the Dream Companion reviewJanitor AI
Before you type
Pick one to five content tags, land on the Janitor+ sales page, then fill in a persona. It wouldn't send our message without one.
Its opener
Medieval Fantasy World RP, with 143 million chats, hands you a character sheet: name, age, looks and a starting scenario.
Our reply
We played a broke, scarred ex-soldier. Back came a dusty road, a purse that 'bears the most painful scar of all', a guard called Berin, and then a 50-silver bounty.
The wait
About two minutes per reply, a 'This reply is taking a while' banner during the first, and a full-screen Janitor+ pitch after the second.
Brilliant free writing at a crawl. Bring patience, or $12.99 a month.
Read the Janitor AI reviewJuicyChat
Before you type
Nothing, though two warnings sat over the message box: this bot needs a bigger model than our free 8K one, and free models have delays.
Its opener
Fantasia Reborn opens like a game: a goddess laughing at how you died, a Skill Ticket, 50 silver and an XP bar.
Our reply
We chose shapeshifting and became a black cat. She played along every step, with rules and a catch.
What broke
By the third reply the silver and XP tracker had gone, and stray underscores had crept into every paragraph.
The meter
Our balance read 0 coins. The model picker prices messages at 2 coins, pictures at 30 and video at 300, and a 'special offer' pop-up appeared twice on the plans page.
The cleverest bots we met, squeezed through a model too small for them.
Read the JuicyChat reviewKupid
Before you type
Our first send set off a name-and-gender form, then a Become Premium pop-up: €3.44 a week on a yearly plan, or €12.99 a week.
Her opener
Flora's scenario: a roommate home at 2am, oddly written as if you're the one in heels and red lipstick.
Our reply
We offered her a glass of water. Three quick bubbles came back, starting with 'Water? Boring.' and heading straight for the flirting.
The paywall
Close the pop-up and the message sends. Plans don't renew, but card checkout had a waitlist, which left crypto or Alipay.
Quick to flirt, quicker to ask for money.
Read the Kupid reviewfuckd.ai
Before you type
Nothing. Pick a character and go.
Her opener
Lucy, a 24-year-old redhead answering the door to her delivery driver, sent a photo with her very first message.
Around the chat
Call and video buttons, Show scene for a picture of the moment, and suggested replies we'd switch off.
The paywall
Pictures and video spend credits, and our free account showed 5 before paying.
The fastest to get explicit, and upfront about what it costs.
Read the fuckd.ai reviewCandy AI
Before you type
Nothing.
Her opener
Riley Reid's Digital Twin sent a video before we'd typed a word, with a disclaimer above the chat saying it's AI-generated.
The paywall
An Unlock banner for unlimited messages, photos, video and calls sat over the conversation from the start.
Polished from the first second, and the sales pitch is just as quick.
Read the Candy AI reviewOurDream AI
Before you type
Nothing for a ready-made character. Building your own costs 5 dreamcoins at the Next button.
Her opener
Nyvi opens with a page of narration: her marriage is ending and she's moving to Santiago with her daughters.
What broke
She called us '[Your Name]'. The persona field was empty, and the bot didn't cover for it.
The good bit
State Trackers beside the chat keep her outfit, mood and the story so far.
Roleplay that opens like a drama. Fill in your persona first.
Read the OurDream AI reviewHoneyPot
Before you type
Nothing. The wallet already held 90 free credits: a welcome bonus and a milestone reward.
Her opener
Sora, a yoga instructor from Tokyo: 'You took your time. I don't wait around for just anyone.'
Our reply
'Sora is typing' for over a minute, then Not delivered. Retry failed, and so did a message to Claudia.
What broke
The status page said every service was operational, and each failed message still counted: 3 of our 20 free ones, gone.
Three days later
We tried again on 18 November, on a different connection, with Claudia and a new Honey. Not delivered, both times.
Great features around a chat that didn't work for us.
Read the HoneyPot reviewPornJoy
Before you type
Nothing.
Her opener
A bot called, really, 'AI Lesbian Chatbot': one block of stage directions, typo included.
The screen
A text box and a send button. No pictures, no voice, no memory or persona settings.
The allowance
10 messages a month on the free plan, which won't get a roleplay past hello.
The worst ten minutes of the twelve.
Read the PornJoy reviewOur own free accounts, nothing paid. Eight apps on 14 and 15 November 2026; fuckd.ai, Candy AI, OurDream AI and PornJoy on 17 October 2026. Prices as shown on the day.

Every AI girlfriend app looks the same from the outside: a beautiful woman, a chat bubble and the word free. The difference shows in the first ten minutes, once you've signed up and said hello. That's when you find out whether she answers, how long she keeps you waiting, and how soon the app reaches for your card.
So we said hello twelve times. Free accounts only, nothing paid, no trials, and messages typed the way people actually text: short, lowercase, a bit of a joke. Eight apps got our attention on 14 and 15 November 2026, four in mid-October. Here's how each one handled it.
- Signed up on free accounts
- 12 apps
- Nothing paid, no trials started
- Wouldn't send our first message
- 2 of 12
- Until we'd filled something in
- Our slowest reply
- 2 min
- Janitor AI, on its free model
- Never answered at all
- 1 of 12
- And still counted the messages
Pick an app, or pick what puts you off
Every log comes from our own account. Tap a gripe to see who did it, or tap an app to read its ten minutes step by step.
Return to the opening comparison or tool.
The paywall turns up in three places
Before hello. Kupid put a Become Premium pop-up between us and our very first message. Janitor's sign-up ended on its Janitor+ page before we'd seen a single bot. Neither was a hard block, but both tell you what the app thinks your first minute is for.
In the middle of a reply. Janitor slid a 'This reply is taking a while' banner under its first answer, offering three times the speed, then a full-screen pitch after its second. JuicyChat parked two warnings over the message box from the start.
On the first picture. The most common, and the most honest. HeyGF's selfie arrived locked, fuckd.ai's pictures spend credits, OurDream charges coins just to finish building a character, and Candy's Unlock banner covers photos, video and calls.
Open full screenshot Kupid: this appeared when we first pressed send.
Captured November 15, 2026
Open full screenshot Janitor AI: good writing, two minutes a reply.
Captured November 15, 2026
Our take: an app that lets you have a proper conversation before it asks for anything respects your time. SpicyChat, Kindroid and HeyGF did. Kupid pitched Premium before we'd said hello.
Fast isn't the same as good
SpicyChat, Kindroid, HeyGF and Kupid all answered within seconds. Janitor took about two minutes a reply and wrote the best scene of the lot: it remembered our character's scar and our empty purse, and built a bounty out of them. JuicyChat answered quickly too, but by the third reply its small free model had dropped the stat tracker the bot's creator had built.
That's the pattern worth knowing. The opening message is written by a person, the bot's creator, so it's the best line you'll get. The third reply is the model. If you test one thing before paying, test that.
"Free" means very different things
It's on every homepage. Here's what it meant on the day:
- No cap we hit: SpicyChat and Janitor AI. Kindroid's free plan is unlimited on a smaller model, but our new account was on the premium one for now.
- A counted allowance: HoneyPot showed 20 messages, Kupid lists 15, and PornJoy gives 10 a month.
- Free to talk, paid to see: HeyGF, fuckd.ai, Candy and Dream Companion let you chat and charge for pictures, video or levels.
- A meter from message one: JuicyChat prices standard messages at 2 coins, and our balance started at 0.
HoneyPot is the one to watch: six messages over two days never arrived, and every one still came off the free allowance. For every plan's free allowance side by side, see our free NSFW AI chat comparison. To turn coins and credits into a real cost, use the credits and subscriptions guide.
Which ones we'd sign up to again
SpicyChat
Community bots with Rulebook meters that react to what you say, fast and free.
Read the SpicyChat reviewHeyGF
Short, separate texts that use her backstory. Free to talk; pictures cost.
Read the HeyGF reviewDream Companion
Live Action levels you climb by chatting, with the meter in plain view.
Read the Dream Companion reviewfuckd.ai
A photo with the first message, and credits that are clearly priced.
Read the fuckd.ai review

